Arguing about religion? Your odds of winning are small. Argue in the Gutter with someone practically in religious robes? The odds drop from small to nun. (Sorry about that one, Lord.)
How Mother Came To Stay by B.D. Keefe
![]() ![]() |
I say the prayers of banishment
until my voice is a ravaged nubble, but I can no more banish her than a
prisoner can rid a dungeon of its damp chill. She is with me still, her breath
heavy in what was once my ear. Her utterings are indecipherable and still I
know their secret meanings. I am practically fetal, yet somehow I remember
snatches of old songs, nursery rhymes, prayers. The Hail Mary and Our Father, for instance, which I don’t recall
uttering past the seventh grade. Their words remain. For a rosary I have only
my own bony knuckles to count.
Mother
Superior. The nickname circulated among the teachers due to her stern affect, along with
the fact that the school grounds had once housed a nunnery. Finally, there was
the matter of her size. She stood well over six feet. Of course she was
overweight, though pointing that out only took away from the sheer immensity of
her presence. She was vast and possessed all the cold power of a glacier. You
saw her coming and your palms clammed up. Your heart sped, or at least mine
did. My callow and stunted little heart.
Sometimes she lies against me heavy
and fetid as a bear in hibernation. I can hardly breathe (not that I breathe
any longer, not in the way of the living), and when I do I’m overwhelmed with
such a stench as to induce nausea. If I still ate food I might vomit. Other
times I'm as a small child in a great hall, and though the hall is shrouded in
darkness, her shadow hangs over me darker still. It presses down with the
weight of an expired star. If days or years existed for me any longer I’d have
spent a few centuries at least pinned to this one lightless and inescapable
place.
To think that I once imagined myself
in the running for the position of headmistress. I memorized all the girls’
names -- over two hundred! -- and would practice little play dialogues in my
head. I’d call the Sarahs and Madisons and Rileys into my imaginary office and
discuss matters frankly, with an air firm yet caring.
When Mother Superior arrived that
first week, those silly fantasies evaporated like dew on morning grass. It was
clear to everyone that she had come to stay.
Even now the guttural murmuring in
my ear occasionally comes together to form something like human words. From time
to time I can even make out snatches of phrases once familiar. They bring me
back to things she used to say, before all of this. She had such a way with
words; she could make you into a queen or the lowest peasant.

Thoughts here repeat endlessly on a
loop, each time around becoming infinitesimally more degraded. It is as if the
needle on…one of those devices that used to play music is wearing a groove into
the thought, dulling it slightly more each time it's played. The memories used
to be so vivid, so bright. Now they are like out of focus snapshots, or photos
damaged in a flood. Some have been diminished to charcoal sketches.
The day I told her I couldn’t do it
anymore we were on a picnic. She’d driven, taking us along the narrow coastal
roads. It was one of the warmer seasons. The names of months escape me now.
They’ve faded like just about everything else. There was tall beach grass and
the smell of something I can no longer name in the air. An odor of the water. A
bottle of wine. Some sort of expensive food. She was angry after I’d said my
piece. She’d bought the food as a special treat. I remember that it was soft
and pungent. I ate just a nibble. Her face was flushed. What was the name of
the color? The same color as the wine. As blood. She drank too much of the
wine. Drank until the bottle was empty. Her hand on my arm was so tight I remember
thinking it would leave a...mark. A mark the color of the dark car. The sky was
getting darker then, too. The clouds were nearly the color of the car. Nearly
the color of the mark I feared she’d leave on my arm. It started to rain.
The deepest sense in this place --
if it can be called a “place” at all -- is that of motionlessness. There is no
ticking clock, no changing light glimpsed through a window. There is no
shuffling of feet. No heartbeat. No nod, no smile. No breeze.
The last real sequence of motion I
knew began with that dark car racing down a road in what had suddenly become
night. I moved, too. First my mouth did. I tried reasoning, then imploring.
Next I moved my arms to reach for the wheel. There was sound and light and the
smell of something chemical I once knew the name of. There was everything all
at once. After a while there was nothing.
Huddled in the dark, I search for
words to describe the state I’m in. So many of my words are gone now.
Huddled in the dark, I say the prayers of banishment that remain
improbably with me. I say them again and again until my voice is a...small,
worn thing. But Mother Superior has come to stay.